Christina Chase
Miss Gay WI USofA 2008
1st Alternate - Bryanna Banxs

Shannon DuPree
Miss Gay WI USofA 2007
1st Alternate - Jackie Roberts

Deja Voo
Miss Gay WI USofA 2006
1st Alternate - Shannon DuPree

Natasha Marques
Miss Gay WI USofA 2005
1st Alternate - Deja Voo

Holly "Hot" Damn
Miss Gay WI USofA 2004
1st Alternate - Miami Richards

Justine D'Zire
Miss Gay WI USofA 2003
1st Alternate - Alexis St. James

DeeDee Winters
Miss Gay WI USofA 2002
1st Alternate - Chantal

CeCe Domino
Miss Gay WI USofA 2001
1st Alternate - Eileen Dover

Kyllie West
Miss Gay WI USofA 2000
1st Alternate - Justine D'Zire

Kelli Jo Klein
Miss Gay WI USofA 1999
1st Alternate - Cass Marie Domino

Neely O'Hara
Miss Gay WI USofA 1998
1st Alternate - Kyllie West

Josie Lynn
Miss Gay WI USofA 1997
1st Alternate -

Sasha Mitchell
Miss Gay WI USofA 1995
1st Alternate - Josie Lynn

DuWanna Moore
Miss Gay WI USofA 1994
1st Alternate -

Dominique Mahon
Miss Gay WI USofA 1993
1st Alternate -
Photo Needed

Mary Richards
Miss Gay WI USofA 1992
1st Alternate -
Photo Needed

Larinda Kelly
Miss Gay WI USofA 1991
1st Alternate -
Photo Needed

Tonya Michaels
Miss Gay WI USofA 1990
1st Alternate -
Photo Needed